Home / Software & Service News / Europe’s top court advised to treat Uber like a taxi company

Europe’s top court advised to treat Uber like a taxi company

Uber is a service that enables people to get from one place to another, but don’t you dare call it a taxi company. That way lies a whole mess of burdensome regulations that the startup has fought tooth-and-nail to avoid. Unfortunately, Travis Kalanick and co. may not be able to get away with the ruse much longer in Europe, as a senior expert has suggested that Uber might just be in the transport business.

The European Court of Justice is being asked to decide on a case between Uber and a body representing taxi drivers in Barcelona. Like many other taxi bodies around the world, the Asociación Profesional Elite Taxi believes that Uber operates as unfair competition. A Spanish commercial court, hearing the complaint, referred parts of the case to the higher, European court, which will rule on it later this summer.

Before the hearing, a question was referred to one of the court’s advocate generals, Maciej Szpunar to weigh in on. He was asked to determine what Uber’s business model was, since Uber positions itself much like so many of those gussied-up hotel-booking platforms. As such, it shouldn’t be bound by the same rules on background checks, safety and insurance. In his opinion, however, Uber is not simply a way for people to connect to drivers, but something far more meaningful.

Szpunar believes that Uber drivers “do not pursue an autonomous activity that is independent of the platform,” and wouldn’t even be Uber drivers without Uber. Secondly, Uber “imposes conditions” on its drivers that go beyond the hands-off approach of so many e-commerce platforms. Szpunar also points out that Uber hands bonuses to drivers who perform well and, conversely, excludes low-performing drivers.

All of these, in Szpunar’s opinion, means that the company “cannot be regarded as a mere intermediary between drivers and passengers.” In addition, the fact that its reason for being is to move people from one place to another, so it’s a transportation company. Put simply, if it walks like a duck and it quacks like a duck, then it’s a duck, no matter how hard Travis Kalanick says otherwise.

We’ve probably explained hundreds of times by now that these advisory documents are not binding decisions. But, opinions like this are often used by the court to make its judgments and frequently reflect how the court is thinking. So while, for now, Uber can continue to go about its business, plenty of eyes will be pointed towards Europe to see what the judges decide.

Source: Europa (.PDF)

Click Here For Original Source Of The Article

About Ms. A. C. Kennedy

Ms. A. C. Kennedy
My name is Ms A C Kennedy and I am a Health practitioner and Consultant by day and a serial blogger by night. I luv family, life and learning new things. I especially luv learning how to improve my business. I also luv helping and sharing my information with others. Don't forget to ask me anything!

Check Also

AI Everywhere: Surprising ways we already interact with artificial intelligence


Paid Content by


If someone were to say to you that you’ve spent all day interacting with artificial intelligence, you’d probably stop and try to recount any instances of accidentally running into a robot

Despite what’s constantly being hammered into our brains via science fiction movies and television, AI comes in many forms, which may surprise you. Not only has artificial intelligence become integrated within a number of industries, but it’s teaching people how to streamline business and optimize their lives.

From social media to public service, some people are interacting with artificial intelligence every single day and it may surprise you how broadly it is being adopted. Here are some ways we’re already using AI on the daily.  Read more...

More about Supported, Artificial Intelligence, Chatbot, Deep Learning, and Virtual Assisstant